Aug. 16, 2025 . Alex Christy

New York Times columnist David Brooks may have officially lost it. On Friday’s PBS News Hour, Brooks reached back over 100 years into the time machine to pull out an analogy that says what President Trump and Texas are doing on redistricting is the equivalent of the German use of mustard gas in World War I.

Moderator Amna Nawaz asked if politics is now nothing more than a power struggle, “David, as you know, the Democratic argument here is, you can't do anything unless you win, right? So, do what you need to do now by any means necessary, so to speak, to win political power, so you can pass through Democratic agendas and Democratic priorities. Is this just where we are now?”

Brooks replied, “I understand the argument. But let's do a little ethical experiment here. You're in World War I. The Germans use mustard gas on civilians, and it helps them. Do you then decide, okay, we're going to use mustard gas on civilians? The — what Trump ordered Abbott to do in Texas is mustard gas on our democracy. Some people would feel, okay, that was terrible. We have to fight that. It's horrible. It's horrible. But we're going to fight back. It's just — that's war.”

[See NewsBusters for more]

You might also like
Donate to uncover the truth
Make a difference and support the Media Research Center