MSNBC's Ruhle Frets Not Enough Abortion Talk by Democrats


Cross posted at the MRC's NewsBusters blog

On Friday's Velshi and Ruhle show, MSNBC host Stephanie Ruhle fretted over Democratic presidential candidates not taking the U.S. Supreme Court seriously enough as an issue, and particularly the Court's influence on abortion rights, as she devoted a segment to the issue. Correspondent Shannon Pettypiece worried that moderates might side with Republicans on late-term abortion if Democrats do not do a better job of talking up their views on the issue.

At 1:22 p.m. Eastern, as she plugged the segment, Ruhle complained about the Democratic debate from Thursday night not making time for "reproductive rights" and the Supreme Court: "The debate last night covered a lot of ground, but I want to cover some other stuff -- big, big issues that were left out. Next, why are these Democrats taking this precious time and avoiding some major topics like America's judges and women's reproductive rights?"

A few minutes later, the MSNBC host introduced the segment by lamenting that Democrats spent no time on the courts being "packed" with conservative judges: "Over nearly three hours, the conservative judges being packed into the federal bench by the Republican Senate didn't even get a mention. Also missing was any talk of women's reproductive rights as more states move toward restrictive abortion laws."

As Pettypiece came aboard, she began:

I'm really glad you brought those up. I think those are two key places we are missing. On the issue of abortion, this is something that Trump and Republicans are going to want to make a campaign issue. Trump has this almost graphic riff he goes on at almost every campaign rally about doctors wanting to kill babies after they're born and ripping babies from their mothers' wombs. I've seen other Republican strategists I've talked to as well saying that they think that this is a winning issue for them, that they can paint Democrats as having gone too far on abortion.

She then lamented:

I do not see the Democrats coming back with a real clear response from that, and this sort of being an opportunity for them to sort of come out and clearly state what their position is and how they would punch back against these accusations that Democrats have gone way too far on abortion rights.

Later in the segment, Pettypiece worried that Democrats are not neutralizing the way Republicans are "characterizing" them on the issue: "I think that the Republicans are creating a trap for Democrats to walk into by characterizing what the Democrats' position is on this issue when Democrats could be characterizing it on their own."

She soon suggested that "moderates" sometimes side with conservatives on abortion "if it's not portrayed right." Pettypiece:

And I think abortion is not just something that is motivating conservative voters, but it does touch moderate voters. When you get into issues of late-term abortion, it is something that moderate voters can become concerned about if it's not portrayed right. So I completely agree with you. I think this is something that is missing.

Ruhle then worried that Democrats are not trying hard enough to work against conservative control of the courts which could take a long time for them to reverse:

This isn't something that can be turned around with the next administration. These people are on the bench for life. Have any Democratic candidates articulated their plan to counter the success the President has had. Whether it's the Federalist Society that's basically created a factory to deliver these judges to be put on the bench -- or you could like how he did it or not -- the success Mitch McConnell has had -- and the way he treated Merrick Garland could be amoral, but it was successful.

Nearing the end of the segment, Ruhle could be heard sighing as Pettypiece recalled that Democratic voters have placed priority on several other issues, even those issues are influenced by who controls the Supreme Court..

MRC Merch

MRC Merch