A Student Newspaper Editor Was Fired For Quoting a Muslim on the Quran


An editor of Portland State University’s student newspaper was fired after posting an exchange on his Twitter account in which a Muslim student detailed the punishment for apostates in Islamic countries.

According to his piece in National Review, Andy Ngo, a former multimedia editor for the Vanguard, posted a clip from an interfaith panel discussion, during which a student asked the Muslim panelist about whether the Quran calls for killing non-Muslims.

The Muslim panelist responded by saying it is considered a crime in Muslim countries to follow any religion other than Islam and that non-Muslims have the option to leave (or, presumably, face death), adding:

And some, this, that you’re referring to, killing non-Muslims, that [to be a non-believer] is only considered a crime when the country’s law, the country is based on Koranic law — that means there is no other law than the Koran. In that case, you’re given the liberty to leave the country, you can go in a different country, I’m not gonna sugarcoat it. So you can go in a different country, but in a Muslim country, in a country based on the Koranic laws, disbelieving, or being an infidel, is not allowed so you will be given the choice [to leave].



Although Ngo was not on assignment at the time, Ngo’s editor-in-chief called him into a meeting to discuss his coverage of the event, which had since been featured on Breitbart.

Ngo’s editor-in-chief, Colleen Leary, reportedly accused him of being “predatory” and “reckless.” Leary allegedly stated quoting the speaker’s comments about the killing of infidels in Muslim countries would threaten the speaker’s life and family. Another person at the meeting reportedly said Ngo should have taken the “current political climate” to heart before posting the clip of the event.

After Ngo defended himself by stating he was merely quoting the speaker, Leary asked him to “step aside” and cited his alleged “history” with conservative media. The editor-in-chief reportedly said his relationship with conservative media was tarnishing the “reputation of the Vanguard.”

Leary issued a response to Ngo’s story in National Review by accusing Ngo of violating ethical standards set forth by the Society of Professional Journalists by paraphrasing the speaker in quotes (despite Twitter’s character rule).

Despite Ngo providing a video clip of the full exchange, Leary said she is still concerned with the “careless oversimplification” in Ngo’s tweet that allegedly creates a “potential danger” for the Muslim student:

I am disheartened by the continued lack of acknowledgement or concern for the careless oversimplification of the panelist’s comments and the potential danger in which he placed a student in his own community. A person’s religious identity or otherwise should never be a factor in whether or not we report full, ethical truths within the necessary context.

Thank you for supporting MRCTV! As a tax-deductible, charitable organization, we rely on the support of our readers to keep us running! Keep MRCTV going with your gift here!

MRC Merch

MRC Merch