SCOTUS to Hear Same-Sex Marriage Cases

If the player does not load, please update Adobe Flash Player or make sure your browser supports HTML5 video.

The US Supreme Court has decided to hear cases challenging California’s Proposition 8 and the federal Defense of Marriage Act.  It is believed that the cases might lead to a federal ruling on whether same-sex marriage is a right. 

NBC News’ Pete Williams reports that he believes the fact that the Supreme Court took the Proposition 8 case is a sign that conservative members believe the proposition will be upheld because they would not have opted to take the Prop. 8 case unless they thought the law would be upheld. This is the first time that the Supreme Court will directly rule on a state same-sex marriage law. 

The Proposition 8 case could be ruled on in a way that does not decide if states can forbid same-sex marriage. A federal appeals court struck down Prop. 8 on the grounds that California could not take invalidate marriages that had been granted after a ruling in favor of same-sex marriage state court. The Supreme Court could decide to only rule on that matter and refuse to decide if states have any right to forbid same-sex marriage.

The Defense of Marriage Act case will not determine whether or not there is a federal right to same-sex marriage, rather it will decide whether the federal government can refuse to recognize same-sex marriages recognized by states. It is expected that the cases will be argued in March and decided in June. 


Check out MRC TV Polls on LockerDome on LockerDome